If you like mulligatawny soup, or even if you don’t like it that much, or you’ve never tried it, you have to try this recipe. This is the best mulligatawny soup recipe out there. Period. It’s that good!
Being a Seinfeld fan I’ve known about mulligatawny soup for a long while… Right, I learned about it from ‘The Soup Nazi’ episode, like millions of others I suppose. Remember the dialogue between Kramer and Elaine?
ELAINE: Do you need anything?
KRAMER: Well, a bowl of mulligatawny would hit the spot.
ELAINE: Mulligatawny?
KRAMER: Yeah. It’s an Indian soup. It’s simmered to perfection by one of the great soup artisans in the modern era.
Contrary to what I learned from the show and what stuck with me for years, mulligatawny is not an Indian soup. It’s a purely English soup made after an Indian recipe. The name roughly translates from Tamil as ‘pepper water’. The original Indian recipe is not even a soup, it’s a sauce that is served with rice.
According to Wikipedia, the original version of mulligatawny soup recipe consisted of a broth from lentils, fried onions and curry powder. Today it typically describes a thickened soup that is strongly spiced with curry powder and nutmeg. Often you will also see vegetables, nuts and rice added. Some recipes make use of port wine.
So, this incredibly delicious soup is a Western invention, but it comes with wonderful Indian flavors. This is one of my two most favorite soup recipes.
Curry powder
At the local spice store I can buy freshly prepared mild, medium and hot curry powder. I prefer mild hands down. Just my personal preference. If you like your soup spicier, substitute mild curry powder for medium or hot.
An even better alternative would be to make your own curry powder to suit your own taste.
Meat
I’ve used chicken breast, chicken thighs and beef meat in this recipe. The winner for me is beef. Followed closely by chicken thighs. Then followed by chicken breast. Chicken breast is good and is an excellent option for calorie conscious people. However, chicken thighs definitely add a lot of flavor and taste juicier.
Sous vide chicken breast and slow roasted chicken breast are both great options if you want tender and very juicy white chicken meat in your soup. Good quality stewing beef or beef chuck is an excellent option as well.
If you have leftover smoked meat (chuck, brisket, pulled pork, pork loin, pork chops, short rib, or kielbasa), use it, it works wonderfully with this soup, lending it a smoky flavor.
If you are using chicken thighs or beef, you can brown them about 1 minute per side over a fairly high heat. Browning chicken breast is a bad idea as it will become dry and rubbery later on, based on my experiments.
Vegetarian mulligatawny soup version
For the vegetarian option, instead of using meat, try adding sauteed oyster or other mushrooms with some onions toward the end of cooking. Satisfaction guaranteed! Don’t forget to substitute butter for olive oil and use vegetable broth.
Cream
Based on my research, it’s customary to add heavy cream to mulligatawny soup when serving, but I think the cream takes away from the depth of flavors in this amazing soup. My family loves it with the cream added though. I personally don’t. You decide for yourself.
Ingredients
- 6 chicken thighs (about 1 lb total, skinless, boneless, cut into 1/2-inch cubes; see notes for substitutions)
- 1/2 cup yellow onions chopped
- 2 celery stalks chopped
- 2 small carrots diced
- 1 leek thinly sliced (white part only)
- 1/2 stick butter (unsalted)
- 2 Tbsp all-purpose flour
- 2 tsp mild curry powder or medium / hot for more burn in your mouth
- 5 cups chicken stock (or chicken broth)
- 1/2 apple cored and finely chopped
- 1/4 cup white rice
- Salt to taste
- Freshly ground black pepper to taste
- 1/8 tsp ground nutmeg
- 1/8 tsp dried thyme
For serving/garnish
- 1 cup heavy cream heated (optional)
- Chopped fresh parsley
Instructions
- Saute onions, celery, leek, carrots, and butter in a large pot over medium heat until they start to soften, about 8-10 minutes.
- Add the flour and the curry, and cook over medium heat for 5 more minutes.
- Add the chicken broth, mix well, and bring to a boil. Simmer for about 30 minutes.
- Add the apple, rice, chicken, salt, pepper, nutmeg and thyme. Simmer for 15 minutes, or until the rice is done.
- When serving, add heated cream (optionally) and chopped fresh parsley.
Notes
Nutrition
If you are looking for more cool Seinfeld recipes, check out The Best SEINFELD Recipes, Crafts, Printables & More! on Bomb Shell Bling.
Alice
wonderful recipe, my new favorite soup. thanks so much for sharing.
Kim
This is honestly one of the best soups I’ve ever had or made. I make a ton of soups! I’m vegetarian so I made it without meat and with vegetable broth and it’s still so delicious.
Linda
Where does all the sodium come from? I want to make this but that’s not healthy.
victor
Most of it came from canned chicken broth which is high in sodium… I usually use chicken stock though and add a little salt to taste. Changed the ingredients to chicken stock, hope this helps.
Barbara
This soup is amazing! Even my anti-soup husband loves it. The seasonings are perfect, and it is a flavorful, substantial fall soup. It is a soup that I’ll be making again and again! Thank you for the recipe!
Kathy
Loved this recipe! Thank you! I’ve never had mulligatawny soup before. I have been missing out!!!
Used leftover chicken breasts …. otherwise followed it exactly. Wouldn’t change a thing!! 🙂
victor
Glad to hear it, Kathy. I have a fantastic lentil soup recipe that I will be posting in the next day or two. I highly recommend trying it. Love it as much as my mulligatawny soup.
john vandermaas
i have been cooking for over 50 years! this recipe rocks!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Cheryl
I tried it with portobello mushrooms and sweet potatoes and red lentils. Very good,
Will
Outstanding! Made this soup over a dozen times and can never have enough of it. Thanks for sharing.
Niki Flynn
I can’t wait to make this recipe for dinner tonight! Do you think it would work if I used lentils instead of rice? My family loves lentils and I saw them used in other mulligatawny soup recipes. Thanks!
-Niki
victor
I think lentils would work very well in this soup.
Barbara
This soup was marvelous! Thank you so much.
victor
You are very welcome, Barbara.
Mich
Wanting to make a meatless version but kids aren’t fans of mushrooms… so thinking of other veggies to add. Would potatoes be good in this?
victor
Potatoes are a good option. Personally, I would add grilled or pan-fried (un-breaded) eggplant. Or zucchini. Else, can’t go wrong with pasta (macaroni, orzo, etc.) Kids love that.
Kevin
Just give your kids meat it is a protein that humans have used for thousands of years you are depriving them of nutrients that can only be obtained through carnivorous means means in a just society you would be locked up for child abuse and your kids sent to a loving family
Momo
Is 6 chicken thighs correct? That seems like a lot for 4 servings. I’m planning on doubling the recipe for a soup party, so that would be 12?
victor
I suppose it depends on the size of the thighs. The ones that I normally use aren’t that big. 6 boneless, skinless may be a pound or so. I think 3 oz of meat per person/serving would be a good amount.
Marc
Authentic Mulligatawny soup did not have meat or cream in it. Furthermore, curry powder was not used, while individual spices were.. I am sure that this is a delicious soup, but it is a creamy meat and lentil soup, as opposed to a “Mulligatawny”
victor
Thanks for chiming in, Marc. So many variations of everything nowadays. My local supermarket sells white cucumbers that look nothing like normal cucumbers. They still call it a cucumber.
Debra Miller
Absolutely delicious. I have made it several times, and the last time used full fat Coconut cream instead of regular cream. Wow, what a lovely flavor. I saved a small dollop for the top of the soup and then squeezed some fresh lime on the top.
Definitely a keeper in our home. even my picky Husband enjoyed the soup.
Thank you for Sharing,
Deb
victor
You are very welcome, Deb. Thank you for your feedback.
Benni
My husband & I are huge Indian food fans (even tho’ apparently mulligatawny is English — who knew?) so I made this recipe tonight & it is definitely my fav. mulligatawny soup to date. That includes the Indian restaurants where sometimes it’s too watery or there’s not enough chicken or flavor. I left out the apple, nutmeg & thyme simply because I didn’t have those ingredients & added a skosh of garam masala because of the nutmeg & the soup didn’t seem to lack anything at all.. I did add the heavy cream to smooth it out & I liked it better than without, but I suppose it’s just up to the cook. BTW, years ago, my husband & I were watching Seinfeld & said, “What’s mulligatawny?” Heh-heh… that led us to a whole new world of food — naan, dal, tandoor, tikka masala, chai… yum. Thank you for the great recipe, Victor!
victor
You are very welcome, Benni. So happy to hear that you found a new recipe that you liked a lot. Thank you for your feedback.
Karen
Our local specialty Market used to make this soup. It was my favorite!! Sadly, they went out of business. I was still craving the soup so did a google search and found Victor’s recipe. The ingredients looked right, so I gave it a try.
It was perfect! I loved it! I have hungry teens so doubled the recipe. Made it with chicken. Will be searching for a spicier curry, the one in my cupboard was too mild, I’ll add mushrooms next time, oh, and I added lite coconut milk rather than heavy cream.
Can’t wait to make it again!
Thanks for the great recipe and history about the soup!
Ruth
Delicious recipe! I grated the apple with a cheese grater instead of chopping it up. It melted right into the soup and the soup was exceptionally tasty.
Berniece
Perfect just what I was searching for!
Karen
I don’t normally comment on recipes, but this is the best mulligatawny we’ve tried so far. We are also big Seinfeld fans. Even our kids liked this soup (they haven’t liked any of the other Mulligatawny recipes so far). I like that it is relatively simple and doesn’t require any far out there kind of ingredients. For the meat, we just used leftover rotisserie chicken. Looking forward to leftovers today!
victor
Thank you for taking time and leaving a comment, Karen. I am glad to hear that you liked the soup. Guess what, just mentioning it made me want it so badly that I will be making it today after work. I have some grilled chicken breasts left over from last night so I will use them in the soup. Can’t wait!
Kathie
I have made your recipe for Mulligatawny soup once and it was excellent! I wasn’t sure if the chicken thighs were supposed to cook in just the 15 minutes that the rice was cooking. So I cooked them separately and added them during the last 15 minutes of cooking. I am making the soup again tomorrow night for company and am still wondering when the raw chicken thighs are supposed to be added? I like your wife’s recipe for boneless skinless chicken thighs cooked in a skillet on the top of the stove. Easy and delicious!
victor
Hi Kathie, glad to hear that you liked the recipe and thanks for writing the detailed feedback. As to the chicken, you don’t need to cook it separately as 15 minutes of simmering is plenty to cook through 1/2-inch pieces of meat. If you do want to pre-cook, then adding the cooked through pieces of meat at the last minute would ensure against overcooking… and I hear you, I love those pan-fried chicken thighs too 😉
Kathie
Thanks for answering so quickly! I was able to follow your advice for my company dinner tonight and the soup turned out great. Everybody wanted more!
victor
You are very welcome!
Whitney Allison Kerr
Yum! I don’t usually cook, but had a craving and found your recipe. As a novice, prep took me much longer, but the end result was worth it. Very yummy and I know tomorrow’s leftovers will be even better. Thank you!
victor
You are very welcome. I find cooking very rewarding, besides you can make just about anything in the kitchen whereas eating out is always limited in general in many ways. I am glad you liked the recipe. Please do come back and try my other recipes.
Boyan Minchev
I’ve tried this mulligatawny soup in the Cheh Republic back in 2015, it was amazing. Thank you for sharing this great soup recipe with us.
Kristyn
I tried a kind of this soup earlier tonight, but I don’t think it had apples in it. If it did then I couldn’t taste them or find them. Are apples in most recipes and will it be ok if I don’t add them?
victor
My apologies about the delayed response, your message went into spam folder for some reason. Apples can be omitted, but I find that tart apples add complexity to the flavor. The apples are boiled and softened to the point that you don’t really feel them. I know they are there, but they are very subtle to notice easily.
Garnet
Sounds delicious but if i use stew beef it will bake longer for the meat to become tender. At what point do you add the chuck or stew meat/
victor
Good point. I would prepare the beef separately and add it at the end. For softer cuts I would pan-sear, slice about 1/4″ thick and add about the same time as chicken. I have done it with chuck, flank and loin cut offs with excellent results. Honestly, I don’t use stewing beef much simply because it’s hard to cook as it consists of different cuts, some of which are very tough. I would definitely stew it first, separately, until tender then use in the soup.
Lara
The soup turned out really, really good! Thank you for the recipe.
victor
You are very welcome.
Brigid
What kind of Apple do you use?
victor
I prefer green, tart apples.
Gm
Mulligatawny is not only an Indian soup but it’s the national soup of India and the name itself is Tamil. While the British were in India, there were some recipes that were Anglicized to suit their milder spice tolerance. What you were talking about is called radar which is literally pepper water that’s a thin spicy soup.
victor
Interesting perspective though very much contradicts my understanding of the origins of this delicious soup. Thanks for sharing.